Dear Karen, if you like the regular wine from a producer, but all you can find in a store is that producer’s “reserve” version that costs a lot more, is the reserve always dependably better?

March 6, 2026

Dear Karen, if you like the regular wine from a producer, but all you can find in a store is that producer’s “reserve” version that costs a lot more, is the reserve always dependably better? The following content is accessible for members only, please sign in.

Dear Kelly,

Sadly, no. It would be great if you could at least count on the more expensive wine being markedly better, but I have sometimes found that the reverse is true. For example, I recently tasted two Pinot Noirs from the same producer in the same vintage. One, the “regular” wine, cost $40. The second and theoretically more special wine cost $80. But I thought the $40 wine was far, far better. So sometimes it makes sense to spring for the most expensive wine from a given producer, but unfortunately, not always.

—Karen

The Single Perfect Cheese for Wine

A Winery Tells Its Story—The Press Release of the Future

Dear Journalists and Influencers:

The following content is accessible for members only, please sign in.